When it comes to waterproof backpacks, one of the most critical design choices is the closure system. There are two primary options: the rolltop and the zipper. Each has its unique advantages and disadvantages, making it a matter of personal preference and intended use.
Rolltop Backpacks
Rolltop backpacks, as the name suggests, feature a top that can be rolled down multiple times and secured with straps or buckles. This design creates a highly water-resistant seal, making them ideal for outdoor activities like hiking, fishing, and kayaking.
Pros of Rolltop Backpacks:
-
Superior Water Resistance: The rolltop design provides exceptional water resistance, even in heavy rain or submersion.
-
Adjustable Capacity: By adjusting the number of rolls, you can change the backpack's capacity to accommodate different gear loads.
-
Sleek and Minimalist: Rolltop backpacks often have a clean and minimalist aesthetic.
Cons of Rolltop Backpacks:
-
Less Convenient Access: Opening and closing a rolltop backpack can be less convenient than a zipper, because with a zipper you can typically access deeper into the bag.
-
Limited Organization: The interior of a rolltop backpack can be less organized compared to a zippered backpack due to having to dig deep into the bag. However this can be avoided with effective organization like packing cubes or dividers.
Zippered Backpacks
Waterproof zippered backpacks, on the other hand, use a traditional zipper closure with big teeth and a water stopping gusset. They come in various styles, from simple single-zipper designs to more complex models with multiple compartments and zippers.
Pros of Waterproof Backpacks with Zippers:
-
Deeper Access: Zippers provide access to the backpack's contents, making them convenient for everyday use and activities that require frequent gear retrieval.
-
Better Organization: Zippered backpacks often have multiple compartments and pockets, allowing for better organization of items.
-
Structure: Zippered backpacks usually provide extra structure to the bag making it easier to initially load.
Cons of Zippered Backpacks:
-
Reduced Water Resistance: While zippered backpacks can be waterproof, they may not offer the same level of water resistance as rolltop designs, especially in extreme conditions.
-
Bulkier: Zippered backpacks can sometimes be bulkier and less streamlined than rolltop backpacks.
-
Zipper Struggles: Waterproof zippers should be sturdy, but that sturdiness can make them challenging to zip and unzip.
Which is Right for You?
The choice between a rolltop and a zippered backpack ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences. If you prioritize water resistance, minimalist design, and expandable storage, a rolltop backpack may be the best option. However, if you value easier access, more organization, and more structure, a zippered backpack could be more suitable.
Our durable waterproof bags are built for the wettest conditions yet sleek enough to be worn anywhere. Their versatile nature makes them ideal for different activities and adventures.
